Comments on: Response to The Jewel of Madina http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/ Encouraging steadfastness in times of trial... Thu, 29 Oct 2009 21:15:12 +0000 http://wordpress.com/ hourly 1 By: Saeed http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-80 Saeed Thu, 09 Oct 2008 11:48:57 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-80 Inshallah these people will see the reponse from Allah (S.W.T) very soon. Already we have an example of Abu Lahab in Quran (Surah Lahab)who used to desrespect our Beloved prophet (P.B.U.H). In answer to this, other then the strong protest at every level, we need to make sure we take the right path of Islam and get all Sunnats of our prophet (P.B.U.H) in our life. Inshallah these people will see the reponse from Allah (S.W.T) very soon. Already we have an example of Abu Lahab in Quran (Surah Lahab)who used to desrespect our Beloved prophet (P.B.U.H).

In answer to this, other then the strong protest at every level, we need to make sure we take the right path of Islam and get all Sunnats of our prophet (P.B.U.H) in our life.

]]> By: Muhammad Imran http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-79 Muhammad Imran Thu, 09 Oct 2008 09:51:40 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-79 Please read my first sentence 'I totally agree with the author' as 'I agree with the opening note of the thread' Please read my first sentence ‘I totally agree with the author’ as ‘I agree with the opening note of the thread’

]]> By: Muhammad Imran http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-78 Muhammad Imran Thu, 09 Oct 2008 09:38:40 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-78 I totally agree with the author. I see the following reasons for all that happening with Islam/Muslims: 1. We are weak and in the world 'Might is Right' as we see all around. So we must make ourselves stronger and such people will be afraid of you and will listen to you. 2. The love of Allah and His Messenger (Peace be upon him) lies in Their Obedience (which i think most of us very very weak on). 3. The media is presenting Muslims as terrorists. Such incidences will give heat to Muslims emotions and few of us will react it in a way the Media wants and they will portray this as Terrorism. I think that we must work on point 1 and 2 and a time will come when we will not be having such incidences. I totally agree with the author. I see the following reasons for all that happening with Islam/Muslims:

1. We are weak and in the world ‘Might is Right’ as we see all around. So we must make ourselves stronger and such people will be afraid of you and will listen to you.

2. The love of Allah and His Messenger (Peace be upon him) lies in Their Obedience (which i think most of us very very weak on).

3. The media is presenting Muslims as terrorists. Such incidences will give heat to Muslims emotions and few of us will react it in a way the Media wants and they will portray this as Terrorism.

I think that we must work on point 1 and 2 and a time will come when we will not be having such incidences.

]]> By: Haseeb http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-77 Haseeb Thu, 09 Oct 2008 07:06:46 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-77 Mr. Jack, on a general note, response over such issues or any other issue where your loved one or your beloved is involved and is being accused or made fun of in a senseless manner, would you not feel anything ? your wife is accused by people on baseless grounds and you will keep quiet ? your father was disrespected by someone right in front of you and you will stand there and watch ? it all depends on how much you love and respect your near ones. For us Muslims, our Prophet and whoever was related to him are respectful there response to such acts is directly proportional to how much you respect / love the accused. By coming up with statements like all Muslims are idiots is equally senseless, your analysis is limited and one sided at the same time. I do not say that violence is the reaction, in fact I am of the opinion that every relegion and culture should be respected. It is human nature to respond to such issues, then why come up with such kiddish tactics of raising uproars ? what for ? what's the reason , why don't you try to avoid issues that can raise conflicts and hostility ? Hope you understand what I mean. Mr. Jack, on a general note, response over such issues or any other issue where your loved one or your beloved is involved and is being accused or made fun of in a senseless manner, would you not feel anything ? your wife is accused by people on baseless grounds and you will keep quiet ? your father was disrespected by someone right in front of you and you will stand there and watch ? it all depends on how much you love and respect your near ones.

For us Muslims, our Prophet and whoever was related to him are respectful there response to such acts is directly proportional to how much you respect / love the accused. By coming up with statements like all Muslims are idiots is equally senseless, your analysis is limited and one sided at the same time.

I do not say that violence is the reaction, in fact I am of the opinion that every relegion and culture should be respected. It is human nature to respond to such issues, then why come up with such kiddish tactics of raising uproars ? what for ? what’s the reason , why don’t you try to avoid issues that can raise conflicts and hostility ?

Hope you understand what I mean.

]]> By: aji http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-76 aji Thu, 09 Oct 2008 03:34:46 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-76 mr.jack..r u good christianity..? i have one question for you..in christian bible never sad jesus is god....give me smart answer our god is man or women...?... a bout the jewel of madina no comment mr.jack..r u good christianity..? i have one question for you..in christian bible never sad jesus is god….give me smart answer our god is man or women…?… a bout the jewel of madina no comment

]]> By: Jack http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-74 Jack Wed, 08 Oct 2008 17:33:47 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-74 One more example of Islamic tears over some literature. When do you grow up? I mean see at our christianity, there are so many critics and cases against bible, we never gone for violence. By crying over such books, you are giving more popularity to these kind of materials. And I was expecting sensible analysis over topic. But I think ALL MUSLIMS ARE IDIOTS. AS STUPIDITY GOES INTO THEIR VEINS. One more example of Islamic tears over some literature. When do you grow up? I mean see at our christianity, there are so many critics and cases against bible, we never gone for violence. By crying over such books, you are giving more popularity to these kind of materials. And I was expecting sensible analysis over topic. But I think ALL MUSLIMS ARE IDIOTS. AS STUPIDITY GOES INTO THEIR VEINS.

]]> By: Hafiz http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-72 Hafiz Tue, 07 Oct 2008 16:52:57 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-72 Hi Mukarran, That is a wonderful idea. Since she is on route to making quick $ by writing this book, we need to act approperiately and send everybody her book as pdf. I will not apent a dollar on this book unless i get it for free. I have my free well not to support such kind of authors. Hi Mukarran,
That is a wonderful idea. Since she is on route to making quick $ by writing this book, we need to act approperiately and send everybody her book as pdf. I will not apent a dollar on this book unless i get it for free. I have my free well not to support such kind of authors.

]]> By: Mukarram Syed http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-71 Mukarram Syed Tue, 07 Oct 2008 07:06:19 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-71 Jewel of Madina Whatever else it may be, it is also about making money. Let us respond appropriately. Make pdf or word copies of the book and email it to all, I mean millions. Nobody will need to pay and buy. Do that to all such ventures. Jewel of Madina
Whatever else it may be, it is also about making money. Let us respond appropriately. Make pdf or word copies of the book and email it to all, I mean millions. Nobody will need to pay and buy.

Do that to all such ventures.

]]> By: Abdul Malik http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-69 Abdul Malik Fri, 03 Oct 2008 19:27:23 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-69 Reply to Abu Tahir Al-Jannabi: It is all about freedom of speech, is it n't? Even "true fanatics" have rights, including freedom of speech and freedom of action! Let the Dua get an ANSWER from Allah! Chill. You have your freedom of speech and others equally have freedom of action! I am just wondering why the author of the Jew-el of Madina, has used the name of Allah, in a distorted and diminutive way? i.e. al-Lah? Reply to Abu Tahir Al-Jannabi:

It is all about freedom of speech, is it n’t?

Even “true fanatics” have rights, including freedom of speech and freedom of action!

Let the Dua get an ANSWER from Allah!

Chill. You have your freedom of speech and others equally have freedom of action!

I am just wondering why the author of the Jew-el of Madina, has used the name of Allah, in a distorted and diminutive way? i.e. al-Lah?

]]> By: Abu Tahir Al-Jannabi http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/2008/09/15/response-to-the-jewel-of-madina/#comment-66 Abu Tahir Al-Jannabi Wed, 17 Sep 2008 13:03:16 +0000 http://alistiqaamah.wordpress.com/?p=109#comment-66 "May Allah paralyze the tongues and limbs of those who knowingly and maliciously slander our beloved RasulAllah" Wow, you sound like a true fanatic. “May Allah paralyze the tongues and limbs of those who knowingly and maliciously slander our beloved RasulAllah”

Wow, you sound like a true fanatic.

]]>